Monday, August 10, 2009

Chase's Chasm

The two party system does not represent the American people. The majority of the people must make compromises in their beliefs to find a party with which to align themselves. Any potential candidate must compromise his or her own beliefs to gain the nomination of one party or the other for without the support of either the Democratic or Republican Party any candidate, with few exceptions, is condemned to obscurity.

Our nation’s founding fathers put little faith in political parties. George Washington refused allegiance to any political party during his Presidency. Benjamin Franklin believed that parties provoke confusion. And Alexander Hamilton, James Madison and John Jay warned against the evils to the general public that a “spirit of faction” would cause. But despite these warnings, by as early as the end of the 1700’s two opposing factions emerged representing different opinions about the role of the federal government. The Federalist wanted a strong central government that would dominate the states, thus ensuring national unity. The Republicans held that the individual states should have more power. While the members of these two opposing parties disagreed over the distribution of power, they agreed on most moral, economic, social, and foreign policy issues such as slavery, domestic trade, the family, and isolationism.

During the 1800’s the chasm between the parties widened, especially over the issue of slavery. The Federalist became the Republicans and opposed slavery and the secession of the South, and the Republicans became the Democratic-Republicans, or the Democratic Party and declared support for slavery and secession.

I think it can be safely said that the two party system of the mid to late 1800’s literally divided our nation. The question that needs to be answered now is, are we going to allow history to repeat itself? We need to learn to be Americans first and to place the importance of “towing the party line” a far distant second. We need to learn to form our opinion on each individual negotiable matter through a careful review of all the relevant facts. We need to find moral common ground on the issues at hand.

How long will we put up with dishonest and corrupt two party system? We need to let it be known that we will no longer tolerate candidates lacking integrity and whose records show the corruption that pervades so deeply the representation we have come to accept and sadly expect. Every American needs to ask him or herself if they trust our government. If the answer is “no”, then we have been duped and it is time we take our government back from the interlopers who now occupy the offices of those who are suppose to do our bidding.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

In your article you condemn the two party system for limiting our government and citizen's choices. I cannot agree more with you on this issue. The republicans and democrats have passed laws that have made it almost impossible for a new party to compete with them. Even Ross Perot with millions of his own money going into his presidential campaign did not qualify for any public funding that the republican and democratic candidates get. And I agree completely that the majority of people do not fit into the small moulds of either party.

Major reform is needed to correct the stagnant political environment that the two current controlling parties have created. One possible way would be to level the playing field by placing strict regulations on campaigning. This could be achieved by lowering the amounts that candidates can spend on campaigns and providing outlets such as public television where each candidate can receive equal time. This would give new political parties a chance to compete with the major parties that have all of the funding. A more extreme reform would be to eradicate political parties and have all candidates run as independents with their personal political ideology as their platform.

Whatever measure is taken change is needed. I believe that the two party system is largely responsible for citizens choosing a party and refusing any further debate. They become parrots of Fox News or CNN and do not attempt to actually educate themselves on the subjects being debated. As you said in your article, political parties divide the nation. If we hope to improve our nation we need to base our opinions off of facts, not political parties.

Josh's governmental thoughts said...

In Chase Carney's article, "Chase's Chasm," I must say while I read it, I felt like he had taken my exact thoughts and rewrote them in this beautifully-written article. The two-party system we currently have ruined Americans and therefore America. As Chase points out, our Founding Fathers knew ahead of time that the parties would put a cruel divide between Americans.

I understand that it's part of our wonderful democracy that people can peacefully disagree with each other. However, I'm not sure if Republicans really disagree with Democrats, or vice versa. Citizens now just use their party as a crutch to their own opinions and use the party to voice their personal opinions. That is a counterproductive part of our democracy. There are so many uneducated Americans. Just look at the polls and the general political knowledge of the American citizens. It is extremely low. Then look at party affiliation and it is disproportionately high. What that says to me is that these uneducated people just follow their family or friends, join a party, and neglect to ever really think for themselves.

There are so many different issues: social, economic, domestic, foreign affairs, etc. How can a single party possibly cater to an individual's every opinion???